Moore's Coda...
...is an excerpt from George Orwell's 1984, describing the division of the world into three totalitarian superstates, Oceania, Eurasia, and Eastasia, who remain in a constant state of war with one another, in order to maintain perpetual and total control over their populations, to the point of controlling historical memory. If this analogy is supposed to be apposite of anything, then Moore is suggesting that the USA, Iraq, and al-Qaeda are morally equivalent, and also the USA is already a totalitarianism or on its way to becoming one. These ideas belie themselves, so I won't comment on them any further.
I will say, however, that this use of Orwell is preposterous. That portion of 1984 is specifically not Orwell's own voice; it is first presented as the work of the dissident leader Emmanuel Goldstein (a stand-in for Trotsky), and later turns out to be a forgery composed by Oceania's Inner Party. At the end of the book, it's anyone's guess whether the world is as it's presented in those pages; in any case, The Book is a crude Trotskyist tract, containing none of the nuance that Orwell required in his own political writing. If Moore had read a bit more, he might have noticed that Orwell's main opponents were Western leftists who before WWII favored neutrality with fascism (as if such a thing were possible) and later contorted themselves to excuse the atrocities of Soviet communism. Notice that Orwell despised pacifism, because he suspected that outside certain small religious communities, it harbored a desire for the defeat of Western liberalism. If by chance Moore is aware of this, then his conscription of Orwell is a transparently cynical abuse of the man's legacy.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home